Monday, March 10, 2014
The risks of treating high blood pressure in the elderly: LESLIE KERNISAN, MD, MPH
When it comes to high blood pressure treatment in the elderly, the plot continues to thicken.
Last December, a minor controversy erupted when the JNC hypertension guidelines proposed a higher blood pressure (BP) treatment target (150/90) for adults aged 60+.
And now this month, a study in JAMA Internal Medicine reports that over 3 years, among a cohort of 4961 community-dwelling Medicare patients aged 70+ and diagnosed with hypertension, those on blood pressure medication had more serious falls.
Serious falls as in: emergency room visits or hospitalizations for fall-related fracture, brain injury, or dislocation of the hip, knee, shoulder, or jaw. In other words, we talking about real injuries and real patient suffering. (As well as real healthcare utilization, for those who care about such things.)
How many more serious falls are we talking? The study cohort was divided into three groups: no antihypertensive medication (14.1%), moderate intensity treatment (54.6%), and high-intensity treatment (31.3%).
Over the three year follow-up period, a serious fall injury happened to 7.5% of those in the no-antihypertensive group, 9.8% of the moderate-intensity group, and 8.2% of the high-intensity group. In a propensity-matched subcohort, serious falls happened to 7.1% of the no-treatment group, 8.6% of the moderate-intensity group, and 8.5% of the high-intensity group. (Propensity-matching is a technique meant to adjust for confounders — such as overall illness burden — between the three groups.)
The methodologists in the audience should certainly read the paper in detail and go find things to pick apart. For the rest of us, what are the practical take-aways?
The main one, in my mind, is that when it comes to people aged 70+, there are more risks to treating high blood pressure than are commonly recognized by clinicians and patients. As the study authors note, real-world Medicare beneficiaries often have more chronic conditions than the older adults who are enrolled in randomized trials of blood pressure treatment.
Reducing the risk of cardiovascular events (the main purpose of treating high blood pressure) is laudable, but it’s been hard to prove a benefit to getting most people’s blood pressure below 150/90.
Given the findings of this study, we should be probably be more careful about starting — and continuing — treatment with blood pressure medications in elderly patients. And we should be especially careful when it comes to patients who seem prone to falls, or who are experiencing blood pressure levels well below the target of 150/90.
Because right now, when it comes to treating high blood pressure in older adults, we are often not careful. Meaning that many clinicians don’t:
Now, I’d love to see all primary care clinics for older adults implement the ideas above, but I’m not going to hold my breath. All of these ideas require a little more time, which is tough to find in today’s busy primary care environment.
And that extra time is something that patients and families have to contribute as well. Whether it’s time coming back to the office a little more often, or time tracking BP at home and connecting remotely with the clinical team: until we have the technology and systems to make monitoring and communication much easier, being more careful means patients and families will have to put in a little more effort.
Last but not least, we don’t know if outcomes would improve if the strategies above were routinely used in primary care. Specifically, we don’t know how changing our approach to blood pressure might reduce falls and other bad outcomes in older adults. (This JAMAstudy found that telemonitoring and pharmacist-managed medication adjustment improved BP control, but it’s a younger population and didn’t study potential harms of treatment.)
Still, I do recommend older adults get a good home blood pressure cuff, preferably one with the tech capabilities to make it easy to share data with a clinical team. If there have been any falls or near falls, taking a closer look at what is happening with blood pressure could very well help.
Click here to read more